Skip to content
Dorshorst Auctions, established 1990
Notes

What Is a Buyer's Premium? Hammer Price, Fees and Your Real Total

Dorshorst Auctions · November 15, 2026 · 7 minute read

Hands tapping a blue calculator on a wooden desk beside a keyboard, plant and yellow mug
Do the math before you bid: the number that matters is the total at the bottom of the invoice, not the winning bid.Photo: Towfiqu barbhuiya on Unsplash

A buyer's premium is a fee the winning bidder pays on top of the hammer price, which is the winning bid itself. It is usually a percentage of that bid. Dorshorst Auctions charges none, but an invoice can still carry a card fee, sales tax and shipping, so budget from the total.

The hammer price is the winning bid: what a lot sells for when bidding closes. A buyer's premium is a separate charge the auction adds on top. It is one reason two people can win lots at the same hammer price at two different sales and pay noticeably different totals.

At our sales there is none. The header on our August 2026 sale read "No Buyer's Premium," and our Terms of Service say the same. What you do pay is covered below, line by line, with a real past lot as the example, so you can set a maximum bid from the number that actually leaves your card.

What is a buyer's premium?

A buyer's premium is a charge the winning bidder pays on top of the hammer price. It is usually a percentage of the winning bid, and Wisconsin's auctioneer rules require written notice of it before the auction begins.

Wisconsin's rules call it a "buyer's fee or surcharge." SPS 120.02 defines it as an amount "usually based on a percentage of the successful bid, charged to the successful bidder," either added to the bid or paid separately. SPS 126.02 lists it as unprofessional conduct for an auctioneer to charge one without first posting written notice of the percentage or amount.

A quick hypothetical shows the math. Say a sale charges a 10% premium (a made-up rate for illustration, not a typical or average one) and you win a lot at a $100 hammer price. You owe $110 before any card fee, tax or shipping. Win it at $150 instead and the premium grows with the bid, to $15.

One more Wisconsin wrinkle: on a taxable sale, the premium gets taxed too. The Department of Revenue's guide for auctioneers, Publication 217, says the taxable sales price in an online auction includes any "buyer's fee" charged in addition to the winning bid. A premium is also a separate question from reserves; our guide to the absolute auction covers those.

Hammer price vs final price: the lines on an auction invoice

The hammer in "hammer price" is the auctioneer's gavel, and the law still uses the image. Wisconsin's version of the Uniform Commercial Code, Wis. Stat. 402.328, says a sale by auction "is complete when the auctioneer so announces by the fall of the hammer or in other customary manner." Online there is no hammer. At our sales on HiBid, each lot ends on a one-minute soft close, and a bid in the final minute pushes that lot's close back another minute. The winning bid when the clock finally runs out is your hammer price.

A plain wooden gavel lying on a weathered gray wooden board, seen from above
The hammer price takes its name from the auctioneer's gavel; in an online sale, the soft close does the gavel's job.Photo: Wesley Tingey on Unsplash

Here is every line that can sit between that number and your total, and how each one works at our sales, taken from our Terms of Service and FAQ.

What can appear on an auction invoice
LineWhat it isAt Dorshorst Auctions
Hammer priceThe winning bid when the lot closesSet by the bidding on HiBid
Buyer's premiumA charge added on top of the hammer price, usually a percentageNone
Card transaction feeA charge for paying by credit card4% on credit card payments; cash only if arranged before the close
Sales taxWisconsin sales tax on taxable sales5.5% where applicable
Shipping and handlingThe cost to pack and send a lotSmall lots: $10.00 handling plus the actual USPS or UPS cost; larger lots are pickup only

Your invoice is emailed after the sale closes and shows the exact figures for your lots.

The out-the-door number: budget from the total, not the bid

Here is the habit we suggest. It is our editorial judgment, not a rule: decide the most you will pay out the door, then work backward to a bid. The bid is only the first line. The out-the-door number is what actually leaves your card.

A real past lot makes it concrete. Lot 428 in our September 2026 estate collection sale, a Snap-on RRA62 series road chest with a lift lid, sold for $200.00 on September 21, 2026. That is a past result, and it is the hammer price. Here is how the other lines work under our terms:

  • Hammer price: $200.00 (a past result)
  • Premium: none
  • Credit card transaction fee: 4%, if you pay by card
  • Wisconsin sales tax: 5.5%, where it applies
  • Pickup or shipping: pickup in Deerfield during the posted window; shipping ($10.00 handling plus actual postage) is only for small lots, and larger lots are pickup only

We have deliberately not added those into one figure. The exact way the card fee and tax are figured shows on your invoice, and guessing at it is how budgets drift, so treat each as its own line and read the real figures when the invoice arrives. The comparison that matters is simpler: at a sale that charges a premium, the same hammer would carry that premium too, as one more line beside the card fee and tax. With no premium, the hammer price is the only number you compete on.

Red Snap-on road chest with lift lid open and rows of drawers on carpet
Lot 428 from our September 2026 estate collection sale, a Snap-on RRA62 series road chest, sold for $200.00 on September 21, 2026: a past result, shown here as the hammer price, kept apart from any card fee or tax.

Our bidding tips build the same habit into four short steps, starting with setting your total budget.

Auctions with no buyer's premium: what changes for you

Without a premium, the hammer price sits much closer to your real cost and the math gets simpler. You compete on one number, and the price you bid is the price of the lot.

No premium does not mean no costs. At our sales you will still see:

  • A 4% transaction fee on credit card payments. Cards are charged within 24 hours after the close; to pay cash, arrange it before the close.
  • 5.5% Wisconsin sales tax where it applies.
  • Shipping on small lots for a $10.00 handling fee plus the actual USPS or UPS cost, sent within 7 days after the pickup window. Larger lots are pickup only.

Everything sells as is, where is, and every bid is a binding offer to purchase, so read the description and look at every photo before you commit. If condition matters, call Marv at (608) 628-1631 to book a preview. Our FAQ covers payment, pickup and shipping in more detail.

Green and yellow 1/64 scale four-wheel-drive farm tractor with triple wheels beside its box
Lot 286 from our August 2026 multi-estate sale, a 1/64 John Deere 9420 tractor by Ertl: if a small lot like this ships, the $10.00 handling fee and postage join your total.

Sales tax on auction purchases in Wisconsin

Wisconsin's state sales tax is 5%, and Dane County, where Deerfield sits, adds a 0.5% county tax, according to the Department of Revenue's sales tax rate chart. Together that comes to 5.5%, the rate named in our terms and the rate on a lot picked up in Deerfield.

Tax is not automatic on every purchase. Publication 217 lists exempt auction sales, including sales where the buyer claims an exemption (with a resale certificate, for example) and sales of personal farm property or personal household goods that meet three conditions, one being that the auctioneer holds five or fewer auctions at that location in the calendar year. It also says online auction sales generally take place where the buyer receives the item. Our terms spell out how that works at our sales: a buyer with a valid Wisconsin exemption can email the certificate, and out-of-state buyers are exempt from Wisconsin sales tax on shipped items, though they may owe use tax at home. Picking up in Wisconsin changes that unless you present a valid resale certificate.

One detail for coin buyers: Publication 217 lists coins of the United States sold as collector's items above face value among the things the 5% state tax applies to.

Ten Eisenhower dollar coins spread on a maroon towel beside a handwritten lot tag
Lot 245 from our August 2026 multi-estate sale, ten Eisenhower dollars: Wisconsin's Department of Revenue lists US coins sold as collector's items above face value among taxable sales.

When to ask a tax professional

This is general information, not tax advice. If you buy for resale, for a business or for a nonprofit, or you are unsure whether use tax applies in your home state, ask your accountant or the Wisconsin Department of Revenue before the sale closes, and send any exemption certificate early, since cards are charged within 24 hours after the close.

How to set a max bid from your out-the-door number

HiBid lets you enter a maximum bid and then bids for you in standard increments, raising you only as far as it needs to. Your max is a bid limit, not a spending target, so set it from the total:

  1. Decide the most you will pay out the door for the lot, everything included.
  2. Take out shipping if you need it ($10.00 handling plus postage on a small lot), or plan your trip to Deerfield for pickup.
  3. Leave room under what is left for the 4% card fee and 5.5% sales tax where it applies. The invoice figures them exactly, so do not cut it to the penny.
  4. Enter what remains as your maximum bid. With no premium at our sales, there is no percentage to add on top of it.
  5. Let the soft close work. A bid in the final minute extends that lot by another minute, so sniping will not help, and HiBid emails you if you are outbid.
  6. If you are outbid, redo the math before raising your max. The number that should not move is your out-the-door total.

For more on keeping a cool head while lots close, read The Art of Bidding, and sign up for email alerts so you hear about the next catalog.

Common questions

Is the buyer's premium included in the hammer price?

No. The hammer price is the winning bid when the lot closes, and a buyer's premium, where a sale charges one, is added on top of it. Wisconsin's auctioneer rules describe it as an amount usually based on a percentage of the successful bid. Dorshorst Auctions charges no buyer's premium at all.

Do you pay sales tax on a buyer's premium in Wisconsin?

On a taxable sale, yes. The Wisconsin Department of Revenue's Publication 217 says the taxable sales price in an online auction includes any buyer's fee charged in addition to the winning bid. Exemptions still apply where they qualify. Dorshorst charges no buyer's premium, so there is no premium on your invoice to tax.

Does Dorshorst Auctions charge a buyer's premium on online sales?

No. Dorshorst Auctions charges no buyer's premium, and all bidding runs online through HiBid. The header on our August 2026 sale read "No Buyer's Premium" in the same line as the 4% transaction fee. You still budget for that card fee, 5.5% Wisconsin sales tax where applicable, and shipping if a small lot ships.

How do I know if an auction charges a buyer's premium?

Read the sale terms before you register. In Wisconsin, an auctioneer who charges a buyer's fee must post written notice of the percentage or amount before the auction starts. On HiBid, check the auction description and terms. Ours say it plainly: no buyer's premium, a 4% card fee, and 5.5% sales tax where applicable.

What is the difference between hammer price and final price?

The hammer price is the winning bid. The final price is what you actually pay once everything else is added: any buyer's premium, a card transaction fee, sales tax where it applies, and shipping or handling. At Dorshorst there is no premium, so the gap is the card fee, any tax and any shipping.

Can I avoid the 4% credit card fee at Dorshorst Auctions?

The 4% transaction fee applies to credit card payments. Paying cash is possible only if you arrange it with us before the auction closes, because cards are charged within 24 hours after the close. Call Marv at (608) 628-1631 before the close if you would rather pay cash.

Sources

  1. Wis. Admin. Code SPS 120.02, Definitions (auctioneers), Wisconsin State Legislature
  2. Wis. Admin. Code SPS 126.02, Unprofessional conduct, Wisconsin State Legislature
  3. Publication 217, Auctioneers: How Do Wisconsin Sales and Use Taxes Affect Your Operations?, Wisconsin Department of Revenue
  4. Wis. Stat. 402.328, Sale by auction, Wisconsin State Legislature
  5. Tax Rates: Sales Tax Rate Chart, Wisconsin Department of Revenue

No sale is open right now

We run about seven online sales a year. Sign up for HiBid's email alerts to hear when the next catalog goes up, or see what past sales brought.