
A consignment auction sells your item or collection on your behalf. You keep ownership until the lot sells, and the auctioneer pays you after the sale, less the commission you agreed to in writing. It works best for pieces that already have a collector following, such as trains, coins, farm toys, tools and instruments.
You don't need a whole houseful to sell at auction. A single Martin guitar, a shelf of 1/64 farm toys or a father's coin albums can go into a sale alongside other people's things, with its own lot number, its own photos and its own description. That arrangement is called a consignment auction.
The difference from selling to a dealer is simple: nobody buys it from you up front. The auction sells it for you, the bidders set the price, and you're paid after the sale. Below we cover how auction consignment works, how it compares with a consignment shop, a quick test for whether your piece suits an auction, and the questions to ask before you sign anything.
What is a consignment auction?
A consignment auction is a sale where an auctioneer sells your property on your behalf. You keep ownership until the lot sells; the auctioneer collects from the buyer and pays you after the sale, less the commission your written agreement sets.
Your piece joins a larger catalog rather than getting a sale of its own. At Dorshorst Auctions, single pieces and single collections are consigned into our regular sales, which run online through HiBid about seven or eight times a year.
How a consignment auction works, step by step
- You describe what you have. A phone call or the form on our sell with us page is enough to start, and the consultation is free.
- You sign a written agreement. In Wisconsin, an auctioneer can't run a sale without a written contract with each owner or consignor (Wis. Stat. s. 480.14).
- The item is cataloged. Every lot is numbered, described and photographed, so a bidder far from Deerfield can bid with confidence.
- Bidding runs online. Our sales stay open roughly a week on HiBid and end on a soft close, so a lot stays open as long as bids keep coming.
- The buyer pays and collects. Buyers pick up in a posted window, and small lots can ship.
- You're paid. Settlement comes with a clear accounting of what sold and for how much.
Our sales run with no reserve, which means a lot that receives bids sells to the highest bidder. If that's new to you, read what an absolute auction is before your consultation.
Consignment auction vs. consignment shop
Both are consignment: you keep ownership and get paid when the item sells. The difference is who sets the price and how long you wait. A shop prices your item and puts it on the floor. An auction sets no price, puts it in front of online bidders for about a week, and lets them decide.
| Consignment auction | Consignment shop | |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets the price | Bidders, when the lot closes | The shop, often stepping down over time |
| Timeline | A set sale date and closing time | Open ended; an item can sit for months |
| Who sees it | Online bidders well beyond the local area | Whoever walks into that shop |
| If it doesn't sell | The plan you agreed to before the sale | Whatever the shop's terms say |
| Best fit | Pieces with a collector following | A few good pieces when you're not in a hurry |
A general comparison and our editorial guide, not a measurement. Terms vary by shop and by auctioneer, so read the agreement either way.
A consignment shop can be the right call. A standout piece will sometimes bring more from a patient shop sale, especially when the shop has the right customers. The limits are time and floor space. An auction runs to a deadline, which matters when you're settling an estate or emptying a house on a schedule. Our sell with us page shows how a sale runs from the first call to settlement.

Does it have a following? A quick test for auction consignment
Here's the rule of thumb we'd give a friend, and it's our editorial judgment rather than a measurement: an auction works best for things that people are already hunting for. A collector who has spent years looking for a particular Lionel transformer or a certain 1/64 John Deere implement will watch the catalog, set a maximum bid and compete. Two of those people are what make a price.
Signs your piece has a following
- Collectors sort it by detail. Trains by gauge and road name, coins by date and mint mark, farm toys by scale and model.
- The maker's name matters. Martin acoustics, Stanley hand planes, Disston handsaws, Starrett measuring tools, Rowe Pottery.
- It's signed, numbered or regional. Signed Wisconsin prints by Charles Peterson or Lavern Kammerude draw Wisconsin collectors.
- The original box survived. Boxed Lionel transformers and new-in-box Ertl farm toys are cataloged with the box noted.
Signs it belongs in a bigger sale
Ordinary household goods rarely travel alone. A set of everyday dishes, a recliner or a box of kitchen utensils doesn't carry its own audience, so on its own it won't pull bidders into a catalog. Those things sell best as part of a full household, where the collector lots bring people in and everything else gets seen too. If that describes most of what you have, read how an estate auction works instead.
Not sure which side your piece falls on? That's what the consultation is for. Single pieces and single collections are consigned into our sales regularly, and if an auction isn't the right route for what you have, Marv will tell you so.
How to sell items at auction when you have one collection
A single collection gets the same treatment as a full estate: each lot gets a number, a description and photos. In our August 2026 multi-estate sale, 354 lots shared one catalog, from boxed farm toys to a 1928-S Peace silver dollar. Browse that August 2026 catalog to see how single pieces and small groups sit side by side.
Coins are a good example of a collection that rewards a little care before it's consigned. Heirs often want to polish, sort or split them first, and all three can hurt the sale. Our guide on how to sell a coin collection explains what to leave alone.
Timing matters too. Our sales run about seven or eight times a year, each open for about a week, so ask at the consultation which sale your piece would join. To hear when catalogs open, sign up for auction alerts.
What to ask before you consign
Before you sign with any consignment auction, ask these questions at your free consultation, and make sure the answers end up in the written agreement, not just in conversation. A good auctioneer expects them. This is general information, not legal advice.
- Is the agreement in writing, and do I get a copy? Wisconsin's rules require a written contract and a legible copy for you at signing (Wis. Admin. Code ch. SPS 124).
- What is the commission, and what other fees or expenses apply? The contract must describe the services and what you pay for them, and say which party pays for advertising and other expenses.
- Will buyers pay a buyer's fee? The contract has to say. Our sales carry no buyer's premium.
- When will it sell? The agreement lists the date or period of the sale.
- What happens if it doesn't sell, or the buyer never picks it up? Get that plan in writing. We work it out with you at the consultation.
- When and how do I get paid? Unless your contract says otherwise, Wisconsin law gives the auctioneer 30 days after the sale to give you an accounting and pay what you're owed (Wis. Stat. s. 480.14).
- Is the auctioneer registered? Wisconsin generally requires anyone acting as an auctioneer to be registered (Wis. Stat. s. 480.08), and you can check a credential through the public LicensE lookup on the DSPS auctioneer page. Marv Dorshorst is Registered Wisconsin Auctioneer #344.

When to talk to an attorney first
The agreement includes your statement that you have title and the right to sell, free of liens, or an itemized list of anything that isn't (SPS 124.02). If the piece belonged to someone who has died, is owned jointly, or might be collateral for a loan, talk to the estate's attorney or personal representative, or your own lawyer, before you sign. The same goes for any contract term you don't understand.
How to consign items to an auction with Dorshorst
Start with a description: what it is, roughly how many pieces, and where it is now. Call Marv at (608) 628-1631 or use the form on our sell with us page. A rough description is plenty to start, and we'll follow up from there.
Commission is set at the consultation and put in writing, never quoted off a rate card, and you'll have the terms in hand before you commit to anything. Marv has run auctions from downtown Deerfield for more than 35 years, and our past auctions show the trains, tools, coins, guitars and Wisconsin art that come through.
Common questions
How does consignment work at an auction house?
You give the auction the right to sell your item while you keep ownership. It's cataloged, photographed and offered to bidders, and when it sells the auctioneer collects from the buyer and pays you, less the commission in your agreement. In Wisconsin, that agreement has to be in writing before the sale.
How much does a consignment auction charge?
Commission varies by auctioneer and by sale, so there's no single number to quote. Ours is set at a free consultation, never off a rate card. Whatever you agree to, Wisconsin's rules require the contract to describe the services, what you pay for them and which party covers advertising and other expenses.
How long does it take to get paid after an auction?
Check your contract first. Wisconsin law says that unless the contract provides otherwise, the auctioneer must give you an accounting and pay what you're owed within 30 days after the sale. Our settlement comes with a clear accounting of what sold and for how much, and we cover timing at the consultation.
Can I consign just one item to an auction?
Yes. Single pieces and single collections are consigned into our sales regularly, especially trains, coins, farm toys, tools and instruments that already have a following. Call and describe what you have. If an auction isn't the right route for it, Marv will tell you that instead of taking it.
Can I set a minimum price on a consigned item?
Some auctions allow a reserve, a minimum price below which the lot doesn't sell. Our sales run with no reserve, so a lot that receives bids sells to the highest bidder, whatever that bid is. Our guide to absolute auctions explains how a no reserve sale works for sellers.
How do I check if a Wisconsin auctioneer is licensed?
Wisconsin requires auctioneers to register with the Department of Safety and Professional Services, and anyone can check a credential through the state's public LicensE lookup, linked from the DSPS auctioneer page. Marv Dorshorst is Registered Wisconsin Auctioneer #344, so you can look him up before you call.
Sources
- Wis. Stat. s. 480.14, Conduct of auctions, Wisconsin State Legislature
- Wis. Admin. Code ch. SPS 124, Written contracts, Wisconsin State Legislature
- Wis. Stat. s. 480.08, Registration, Wisconsin State Legislature
- Auctioneer (AUC), Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Services