
Breweriana is the advertising and barware of beer: signs, cans, trays, openers, steins and tavern tokens. In Wisconsin, local names carry weight, because the state once had hundreds of breweries and a deep tavern tradition. Most common pieces are common; the brewery, the town and the decade decide the rest.
Clear out a Wisconsin basement and you'll find it: a sign over the home bar, a shelf of cans, a drawer of openers, a stein from a trip, a coffee can of tokens from taverns that closed decades ago. Collectors call all of it breweriana, and it's one of the categories in our past catalogs.
The honest short answer to "is any of it worth anything" is that most of it is common. National brands made signs, trays and cans in very large numbers. What draws interest is usually specific: a small local brewery, a named tavern, an early date, or a piece in original, untouched condition. Here's how to tell which you have, what to leave alone, and how to sell it.
What is breweriana?
Breweriana is anything a brewery, distributor or tavern made to advertise, serve or sell beer: signs, cans, bottles, labels, trays, coasters, openers, tap knobs, steins, glasses and tavern tokens. The beer itself isn't the collectible. The name, the place and the date are.
Wisconsin made a lot of it. Joe Kapler, a curator at the Wisconsin Historical Society, told WUWM in 2022 that the state had nearly 200 breweries by 1860 and nearly 300 by 1890, and that the first known licensed tavern was approved in Green Bay in 1825. That's a long list of names, and collectors look for them. Breweriana sits in our past catalogs alongside Wisconsin pottery, old advertising and signed Wisconsin prints.
Wisconsin breweriana: why the town and the tavern matter
National Prohibition gives every brewery piece a rough timeline. The 18th Amendment, ratified in January 1919, banned the manufacture and sale of intoxicating liquors for beverage purposes starting one year later, and the 21st Amendment repealed it in December 1933. Which side of that gap a piece falls on is one of the first things a buyer will want to know.
Taverns carry the local story. In January 2024, the Wisconsin Historical Society announced that the family behind Madison's Silver Dollar Tavern, opened in 1933 after Prohibition ended, had donated its 43-foot bar, neon signs and other memorabilia for the Society's planned Wisconsin History Center on Capitol Square. When a state historical society saves a tavern's neon, local bar history clearly matters to people.
Tokens like these, some stamped good for one drink, are breweriana at its most local. The faces name the tavern and often the town: Rockdale, Jefferson, Fort Atkinson. You can see how it was cataloged on the Lot 237 page.
Old beer cans worth money? What collectors check
Most old beer cans aren't. Cans from national brands came off the line by the millions, and a shelf of them from the 1970s and 1980s is common. Collectors look harder at a few things:
- Opening style. Older flat-top cans were opened with a church key, and cone-top cans were shaped like a bottle neck. Note which you have.
- The brewery. A small or short-lived local brewery draws more attention than a national label.
- Condition. Rust, dents, fading and scratches matter on cans as much as on signs.
- Whether it's empty. A can or bottle with beer still in it raises a different question, covered below.
Full cans and bottles: ask first
Wisconsin's alcohol beverage law says no one may sell, brew or do anything else the chapter licenses without the appropriate license or permit. The chapter also lists exceptions, including one in Wis. Stat. 125.06(11) for an auction house selling a collection of unopened beer cans or sealed bottles of liquor at public auction to settle an estate or dispose of the collection. Whether a given can or bottle fits that exception is a question for the consultation, so set those aside, don't pour them out, and mention them to Marv. Our list of what not to throw away covers the rest of the basement.
Name, place, period: a three-line label for every piece
Here's the habit we'd suggest for any beer or tavern piece, and it's our editorial judgment rather than a published standard. Before anything gets boxed, give each piece a three-line label: the name on it, the place it came from, and any period clue. A buyer reading "Frisch's Tavern, Rockdale, brass token" knows far more than one reading "old bar coin."
| Piece | Name | Place | Period clue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tavern token | The tavern or owner stamped on it | Town on the face or back | Material: brass, aluminum, wood or plastic |
| Sign | Brewery and brand | Brewery city on the face | Any printed date or maker mark on the edge or back; whether it plugs in |
| Can | Brewery and brand | Brewery city printed on the can | Flat top, cone top or pull tab |
| Stein or glass | Maker's mark on the base | Country or city with the mark | Lid hardware, decoration, any date |
| Tray or calendar | Brewery and brand | Brewery city | Printed year, before 1920 or after 1933 |
Our editorial guide, not a measurement. No single clue dates a piece; write down what you see and let buyers weigh it.
Beer steins value: souvenir or something more
A stein is a beer mug, often stoneware or porcelain, sometimes with a hinged pewter lid. Many were made as souvenirs in large numbers. Others carry a maker's mark, hand painting or an unusual lid that collectors look for. Turn it over: the base is where a mark, a country of origin or a pattern number usually sits.
Steins turn up in all kinds of lots. Lot 184 in the same sale paired a blue-and-white stein with a windmill scene and a signed pottery vase. Leave a stein as it is: don't scrub it or force a stuck lid, and note chips, cracks and a loose hinge plainly. Stoneware steins share a lot with old crocks, and our guide to antique crocks covers reading a maker's mark.
Selling breweriana from a Wisconsin estate
- Leave it as it is. Don't scrub rust off a sign, polish a tray or peel a sticker.
- Leave lighted signs unplugged and say whether anyone knows if they work. An honest "not tested" beats a surprise.
- Keep sets together: a run of trays, a case of matching glasses, a coffee can of tokens.
- Label each piece with its name, place and period.
- Mention full cans or bottles before the sale, not after.
Old signs bring their own questions about reproductions; our guide to vintage gas station signs covers porcelain signs and fakes. Wisconsin beer signs, Madison tavern items and brewery advertising all fit the same approach.
We run estate, household, antique and farm auctions from downtown Deerfield, about 15 minutes east of Madison, and all bidding happens online through HiBid, so collectors well beyond Dane County can see every lot. Single pieces and single collections are consigned into our sales regularly. One request: don't throw anything away until we've looked at it. The tokens and openers families are sure nobody wants are often the ones that draw the most attention.
Common questions
What does breweriana mean?
Breweriana is the advertising and barware of beer: signs, cans, bottles, labels, trays, coasters, openers, tap knobs, steins, glasses and tavern tokens. Collectors care about the brewery or tavern named on a piece, the town it came from and its age, much more than the beer itself, which isn't the collectible part.
Are old beer cans worth money?
Most aren't, because national brands made cans by the millions. Collectors look harder at older flat-top and cone-top cans, cans from small local breweries, and cans in clean, original condition without rust or dents. Keep them as they are, note the brewery and city printed on each, and set aside any that still hold beer.
How can I tell how old a beer sign is?
Start with what's printed on it: the brewery's name and city, any date, and any maker's mark along the edge or on the back. Note the material and whether it plugs in. National Prohibition banned making and selling intoxicating liquors from 1920 until repeal in 1933, so buyers want to know which side of that gap a sign falls on.
Can I sell full, unopened beer cans at an auction?
Ask before you plan on it. Wisconsin requires a license or permit to sell alcohol beverages, with a few specific exceptions, including one for an auction house selling a collection of unopened beer cans to settle an estate. Set full cans and bottles aside, don't pour them out, and tell Marv about them at the consultation.
Are old tavern tokens collectible?
They're local history in your hand. Tokens stamped with a tavern's name and town, sometimes good for one drink, tie straight back to a place. Our August 2026 sale included a box of them from Deerfield-area bars. Keep them together in one container, note every name and town, and don't polish or clean any of them.
Should I clean a rusty beer sign before selling it?
No. Scrubbing, sanding or repainting removes the original surface buyers judge, and nothing puts it back. Leave the rust, fading and scratches as they are and describe them plainly. If it's a lighted sign, leave it unplugged and note whether anyone knows if it works. Let the next owner decide on any restoration.
Where can I sell breweriana near Madison?
Dorshorst Auctions works out of downtown Deerfield, about 15 minutes east of Madison, and breweriana appears in our past catalogs alongside Wisconsin pottery and old advertising. All bidding is online through HiBid. Call Marv at (608) 628-1631 for a free consultation, and leave everything in place until he has seen it.
Sources
- Pour a glass and learn about Wisconsin's brewing and tavern history, WUWM 89.7 FM, Milwaukee Public Media (March 29, 2022)
- Legacy of Madison's Silver Dollar Tavern will live on in future Wisconsin History Center, Wisconsin Historical Society (January 17, 2024)
- The Constitution: Amendments 11-27, National Archives
- Wis. Stat. 125.04, General licensing requirements, Wisconsin State Legislature